Mom fights Facebook's censoring of child's "bum photo" - KALB-TV News Channel 5 & CBS 2

Mom fights Facebook's censoring of child's "bum photo"

Posted: Updated:

(CBS News) - A North Carolina mother tells CBS News she "stands behind" the photo of her daughter that got her temporarily banned from Facebook.

While at the beach, Jill White, a professional photographer, snapped a picture of her two-year-old daughter recreating the pose of the "Coppertone girl" from the 1950s, reported CBS Charlotte affiliate WBTV. She had told the news station that her daughter's bathing suit had been pulled down by the little girl's friend.

After asking the friend's mother for her permission, White says, she posted it online.

After she had been temporarily banned for the uncensored version, Jill White posted an edited version.

"I posted [the photo] on Coppertone's [Facebook page]," White told WBTV. "We thought it would be cute because of the old Coppertone ad and her tan line looked like that."

Then, White said someone reported the photo to Facebook as being inappropriate. Given the option to delete the photo or change the privacy settings, White chose to ignore Facebook's warning, saying she did not believe the photo could be considered either nudity or pornography, which are barred under Facebook's terms of use.

"There's nothing sexual about this photo," she told CBS News in a phone interview.

Facebook disagreed, and banned White for 24 hours -- leaving her unable to post on her profile page or her professional photography page. According to the social network's terms of use, Facebook reserves the right to "remove content that violates our Statement of Rights and Responsibilities. If we determine you've posted something that violates our terms, you may receive a warning or become disabled, depending on how severe the violation is."

When given access to her Facebook profile again, White reposted an edited version of the photo.

"I got back on with another photo, this time a big Emoji face on the area of the butt crack," she told WBTV. "Now it is being reviewed again for nudity and pornography."

She said she was concerned she could be banned for life if the photo was again found inappropriate.

After the incident went viral, angering some Facebook users, Facebook said White was not facing a lifetime ban and that the first photo was not considered pornographic. Rather, the photo displayed her daughter's nude bottom, prompting deletion.

In a statement to WBTV, Facebook said: "With over 1 billion people using Facebook we have to put in place a set of universal guidelines that respect the views of a wide range of people...These policies are designed to ensure Facebook remains a safe, secure and trusted environment for everyone on Facebook."

But White told CBS News she thinks Facebook needs to be more clear about their standards.

"I stand behind it. If they're going to take that photo down -- there are so many photos that have been reported on Facebook they haven't taken down," she said.

And she insisted that the photograph "does not constitute anything [like] pornography."

"As a photographer, that's what a lot of moms like -- the bum photos. It's a mom thing, I suppose."

© 2014 CBS Interactive Inc. All Rights Reserved.

 

  • Most Popular StoriesMost Popular StoriesMore>>

  • Tropical Blog Fri (8/29)

    4 Areas of Interest In The Tropics

    4 Areas of Interest In The Tropics

    Friday, August 29 2014 11:38 AM EDT2014-08-29 15:38:26 GMT
    Friday, August 2910:30amThere is One Tropical Cyclone in the Atlantic Basin.Cristobal (Post-Tropical Cyclone)The Center of Cristobal is last located 545 miles SSW of Halifax, Nova Scotia and is centered at 45.5N 47.1W with Maximum sustained winds of 75mph and a Minimum Central Pressure of 980mb (28.94"). This system is moving NE (055) at 44mph.Watches/Warnings:There are no current watches or warnings associated with this system..Satellite Radar analysis reveals that Cristobal has completed ...More >>
    Friday, August 2910:30amThere is One Tropical Cyclone in the Atlantic Basin.Cristobal (Post-Tropical Cyclone)The Center of Cristobal is last located 545 miles SSW of Halifax, Nova Scotia and is centered at 45.5N 47.1W with Maximum sustained winds of 75mph and a Minimum Central Pressure of 980mb (28.94"). This system is moving NE (055) at 44mph.Watches/Warnings:There are no current watches or warnings associated with this system..Satellite Radar analysis reveals that Cristobal has completed ...More >>
  • Family of instructor killed by 9-year-old with Uzi speaks

    Family of instructor killed by 9-year-old with Uzi speaks

    Friday, August 29 2014 3:36 PM EDT2014-08-29 19:36:40 GMT
    NEW YORK (CBS News) -- The family of an Arizona shooting range instructor accidentally killed by a 9-year-old girl while he was teaching her to use an Uzi said they feel sorry for the child.More >>
    NEW YORK (CBS News) -- The family of an Arizona shooting range instructor accidentally killed by a 9-year-old girl while he was teaching her to use an Uzi said they feel sorry for the child.More >>
  • UPDATE 8-29-14: Soldier charged, officer named in shooting incident

    UPDATE 8-29-14: Soldier charged, officer named in shooting incident

    Friday, August 29 2014 2:21 PM EDT2014-08-29 18:21:37 GMT
    ALEXANDRIA, La. (KALB News Channel 5) -- State Police have charged Mitchel Bethin following an officer-involved shooting involving an Alexandria Police officer.
    More >>
    ALEXANDRIA, La. (KALB News Channel 5) -- State Police have charged Mitchel Bethin following an officer-involved shooting involving an Alexandria Police officer.
    More >>
Powered by WorldNow
Powered by WorldNow
All content © Copyright 2000 - 2014 WorldNow and KALB. All Rights Reserved.
For more information on this site, please read our Privacy Policy and Terms of Service.